Jan 11, 2020

Is adding EVERY city in the USA to negative keywords good practice?

I am running ads for auto repair shops and am struggling with a repeating issue whereas someone in my clients' targeted areas search for auto repair outside of the area and my client ads show. 

For example, say I am running ads in Dallas Texas for "auto repair shops in" as a phrase match and targeting ONLY Dallas county which might have 30 cities.

Now imagine someone who sends little Johnny off to school in Bangor Maine and little Johnny has a car problem. So daddy, in Dallas, my clients' targeted area, searches "auto repair shops in Bangor ME"

Well my ad shows up and he clicks, costing my client $25. 

This happens more times than you you. 

So my thought is to acquire a database of every city and county in the united states. Add those to a master shared negative list. And when I set up a client in say Dallas, I remove the city names for Dallas County from the Master List. 

I know, the negative list would be huge, but maybe this is common practice out there by you Ads gurus and I am just behind in my practice.
Locked
Informational notification.
This question is locked and replying has been disabled.
Community content may not be verified or up-to-date. Learn more.
All Replies (3)
Jan 11, 2020
This is a frequent question
3 points to note:
  1. The method you re suggesting is not practical;
  2. You don't need to include a city name within the keyword. Geo-targeting is set at the campaign level.
  3. The approach to take is to clearly mention your service geo-region and (and car brands) in the ad-copy, so daddy in Dallas will not be confused about the location of the repair facility.
Jan 11, 2020
Google throws geo targeting out the window when it comes to matching. I just paid 20+ bucks for someone looking for a transmission shop in MAINE from the area my client was geo-targeting. 

So when you way "you don't need to include a city name within the keyword" and I big on "best transmission shop near"  someone in DALLAS could search "best transmission shop near Miami airport" and Google's brilliant "AI" would show my ad.
Jan 12, 2020
I see this all the time, but it would account for way less than 5% of relevant searches with city names.
 
Either roll with it, or try to add negatives. Start with the nearest common towns that are outside of the reach of the service.  I typically (in Australia) add the capital cities and states, that is only 20 or so negatives. Much harder to negative every town and city in the USA (there is probably a numerical limit to negatives as well), and keep in mind, if the city name is misspelled, the negative won't work. 
false
11204668313363465735
true
Search Help Center
true
true
true
true
true
73067
Search
Clear search
Close search
Main menu
false
false
false