/youtube/community?hl=en
This content is likely not relevant anymore. Try searching or browse recent questions.
5/21/19
Early heads up: abbreviated public subscriber counts across YouTube 1 Recommended Answer 691 Replies 6946 Upvotes
1 Recommended Answer
$0 Recommended Answers
Last edited 5/21/19
Currently, all creators with over 1,000 subscribers see their subscriber counts displayed differently in different places across YouTube desktop and mobile apps. In some cases, the subscriber count is abbreviated (e.g., 133k) and in other places we display the full count (e.g., 133,017).

To create more consistency everywhere that we publicly display subscriber counts, starting in August 2019, we’ll begin showing the abbreviated subscriber number across all public YouTube surfaces. Third parties that use YouTube’s API Services will also access the same public facing counts you see on YouTube. Creators will still be able to see their exact number of subscribers in YouTube Studio.

So what exactly will this look like? For channels with fewer than 1,000 subscribers, the exact (non-abbreviated) subscriber count will still be shown. Once your channel passes the 1000 subscriber milestone, we will begin to abbreviate your public subscriber numbers on a sliding scale. 



Here are a few examples:
  • If a channel has 4,227 subscribers, the public subscriber count will read “4.2k” until the channel reaches 4,300.

  • If a channel has 133,017 subscribers, the public subscriber count will read “133K” until the channel reaches 134,000.

  • If a channel has 51,389,232, the public subscriber count will read “51M” until the channel reaches 52,000,000.

We know subscriber counts are extremely important for creators and fans alike, so we wanted to give everyone a heads up a few months in advance of this change! We’ll share more specifics with creators as we get closer to the August 2019 date.

If you have any other questions not covered by this post, please drop them in the comments below.
– Jordan (TeamYouTube)
All Replies (691)
5/21/19
There should be a setting where you choose between these, not forcing us to see a specific version
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
Who asked for this? I haven't heard anyone clamoring for consistency on this, and this seems to be a net negative for viewers, because they might have less trust that "4.2K" is real than "4,227".
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
Will this be an optional setting?
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
Congratulations YouTube Team help
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
Hi !
Have you thought that maybe, you could bring more consistency by displaying the full number of subscriber everywhere on the site ? The same goal would be achieved, but a lot less people would be angry for sure ! It would probably be harder to design around, but i feel like a lot of people would prefer precision rather than smoother design.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
thank you
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
I don't want this. No one wants this. People who keep their sub counts public want to show the full number. Why are you wasting your time and resources on an awful change when countless channels like mine are suffering from unfair demonetization with no way to appeal it?
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
why are people upvoting this...
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
Literally no one asked for this.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
Seems great to have more consistency, but wouldn't it be more clear to show the entire number? Just a thought if changes are still being considered.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
No one wants the abbreviated counts. Consistency is good, but you should consistently be showing the full number, not an abbreviation. That's what people want.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
That's great and all, but changing the API to only display these vague numbers? really? Many places, such as SocialBlade, physical counters, and the numerous subscriber count livestreams on YouTube all use the YouTube Data API to get exact numbers. Will it still be possible to get exact numbers via the API at all or will that ability be removed entirely? Because removing the ability to get exact numbers through the Data API entirely would break all of those things that I listed.
Last edited 5/21/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
Thanks youtube team
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
I love this platform, but I am TIRED of seeing new updates that take a step back in innovation. This update seems very useless and out of nowhere. Time could be better spent fixing problems that users have reported across the site, not abbreviating sub counts, which can lead to lost potential business opportunities, and countless other things that will decrease the way we are able to look at our analytics and growth. It will also make it more difficult for creators AND users alike, in the fact that by August, the only 2 ways we will be able to see our ACTUAL subscriber count is either through the new BETA creator studio, or third party websites, which will ALSO be affected by a rounded API.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/21/19
This isn't a great move in my opinion and here's a few scenarios / reasons why:

1. Your example at the moment deducts 300,000+ subscribers from a larger channel's sub count, that's an awful lot of people + progress unaccounted for. Not only might the viewers feel as though they've contributed but but potential business partners could go elsewhere if they believe their quota can't be met (alternatively it could low ball initial offers from them and undermine brand deal opportunities) - sure, you could argue that they'll get in touch then you can send accurate information but what if they never call at all due to this change?

2. I appreciate some channels capitalize on live subscriber counts for "who will reach x first" but that's such a minority of users. Even if you change the channel page numbers, PLEASE leave the API untouched as many of us use third party sites to track trends, growth and patterns of other creators and ourselves to figure out where to steer our own content and what people are actually viewing, it's such valuable information.

3. On that same note, live subscriber counts are actually more commonly used as celebratory tools. How many streamers or content creators do you see with live counts as they approach a subscriber goal. If you were say, 22 subscribers away from a milestone, being able to show that to viewers could be that last little push and influence to press the red button.

My guess is that this is in response to many recent dramas and trying to minimize the visible losses when a creator is amidst it or maybe even to mask occasional subscriber purges when inactive/spam accounts are cleared out. There's also the possibility that it's trying to relieve pressure on creators and better their mental health by sub counts being more vague.

Question: Has there been any consideration to adding an accurate subscriber count to the About page of each channel (alongside lifetime views + join date), that could be a nice compromise?

I totally get wanting to have more consistency across your platforms but delving in and restricting the API too, that just seems a bit aggressive. If either my suggestion or the API can remain the same that'd be great.

I'd love to hear a response on this, cheers - Martyn
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
thank you for ruining the YouTube experience for its actual users even more by favouring corporations instead.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
This is good. It will get rid of cancel culture, and hopefully those stupid live subscriber vids.
Last edited 5/24/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Nobody asked for this and nobody wants this. The does no good at all. I dont care if you change to the abbreviations on the website. Just leave the API alone so live sub count websites can work
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
"We know subscriber counts are extremely important for creators and fans alike," Then why are you changing it?
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Umm, what is the point of changing the API? If anything, live subscriber counts should be built into YouTube
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I think this is a bad idea. I vote no!
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Please don't. Seeing real sub counts is more important than consistency. Also, nobody asked for this. Ask your community about what they want changed instead of pulling garbage like this. Heck, make a survey or something.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
This is another bad decision in a string of bad decisions. It shows how out of touch YouTube and their product team really are.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
How the subscriber count shows is very minor compared to us content creators who cant get monetized because YouTube wont update our requirements being met. It's frustrating for us who want to stay consistent.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Who asked for this? You're essentially hiding actual subscriber counts from everyone. Sites like Social Blade will no longer be able to track in real time, giving fans no way to celebrate milestones with their favorite creators. Why not compromise and keep the accurate API data available but simply the number everywhere else? It'll also make tracking for other purposes like growth much more difficult. Seems like a decision driven by a desire to hide and mislead more than anything else...
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
@MartynLittlewood makes some very sound and sensible reasons for NOT doing this. I'm not a fantastic "geek" like some so API info eludes me but I do know from experience that it's a very important thing when trying to do anything via Wi-Fi (I'd always get "unknown API" notifi's whenever I'd loose my signal) so by changing to an abbreviated sub count might look cleaner if it changes the API as well won't that cause issues for (I'm not sure...)! trying to follow a link or save/dwnld a video?! I'm in agreement with most of the comments that "if it ain't broke don't fix it" is a good rule of thumb to follow. If you're worried about the Apps channels looking clean & more consistent how about you get rid of the "story" cards that pop-up in random places on my "recommendation" feed? I know who I'm subscribed to & if there's anything extra or special they want us to know about they'll post an announcement to follow for all the details besides you can't really "DO" anything on the cards except scroll past or back to what interests you & you still windup following a link to their channel for the additional content, unless you think there's hoards of people who just HAVE TO add a bunch of hearts or smiley faces to someone's card...loose them before changing anything that can actually effect someone's account or their subscribers. As I've read why not post a "poll" before making any changes to the Apps content or appearance and let the actual #'s of those who pay possibly closer attention to exactly what you're App is doing or making your "channel owners" change before being allowed to upload a video. For a short period; due to a change of your policies, I was missing a LOT of great videos because they needed additional editing before being allowed to be uploaded (something to do with specific content + maybe some copyright things) I'm not sure exactly what but I am sure that some channels either had to create a new one just for certain postings or they deleted the channel all together and went to a different platform where they weren't so restricted just because the YouTube "powers that be" wanted things their way (& no there wasn't any legal issue with at least one channel that I know of but, they did a poll to help by letting their subscribers weigh in on total deletion of new channel for certain content, just saying...if you're so worried about people who use your App actually liking it (?!?) maybe you should ask them if the change would be beneficial or just wasted technology because someone HAD to have something to contribute at the last meeting). Just throwing out a few things I've witnessed & since I use YouTube for pretty much ALL my "viewing pleasure" I'm pretty sure there's not much I've missed regarding changes in your App(& I'm also pretty sure others will agree with maybe a little bit of what I've said. TTFN KLP out
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I would rather keep the whole string of numbers, not the abbreviated version. For example, for a person who has 1,800 subscribers, it should not be read as 1K because that would give the false impression to the viewers that the person has 1,000 subscribers when realistically, he or she is pushing 2,000.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
The fact that this angers anyone is absurd. It literally changes nothing. Please stop making a mountain out of a mole hill. Complaining just to complain just to complain is ridiculous. If youtube didn't give you a heads up most of those upset about this wouldn't even notice it. So please take several seats.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Complaints here are valid, full numbers gives users more clarity on how well their channel how other channels are doing.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
So what is the point of this decision? What benefit does it provide?
 Seems like a change just for change's sake
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Maybe now creators will concentrate on content and not so much on numbers. The whole 1K -  4K thing created a distracting frenzy among the small Youtuber community.
Last edited 6/5/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
you guys need to fix my notifications system so my subscribers know when I upload.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
So instead of fixing the broken aspects of the system, such as monetization policies, broken af copyright claims where you can multiple strike the same thing, you make yet another pointless fucking change.

Fuck that, fuck you YouTube.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Be careful, Google. BE VERY CAREFUL. The last three years, you've slowly been making worse and worse decisions that negatively impact the creators and users you've 'upheld' for so long in favor of big business. You're quickly walking a plank to your own digital death.

I'm certain if you keep making dumb decisions like this that push people away as opposed to drawing them in, you'll soon find yourself down a site and billions in profit as creators flock to some new site offering the same or better alternatives to your degenerating platform.

Let me say it once more in case you didn't get my point: BE VERY CAREFUL.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I would much rather see a Consistent REAL subscriber number and the subscriber list available in Beta.  My numbers go up and down every day, but the "Recent Subscribers" names never change in Beta.   Every screen I look at has a slightly different number.  I know I'm small, but that's when it matters even more to have a real number.  The difference between 1986, 1980 and 2k is huge to me right now.  I don't really trust ANY of the subscriber numbers at this point.  Which one is right?!?!?
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Quick question: what is wrong with you? Do you not have eyes to read the waves of comments being hurled at you?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
For all those angry at this think about two things 1) What are really going to loose from this (Don't say those live drama subscriber counts you watch) and 2) The reason they are doing this is to stop the unessesary competition for subscribers so creators can focus on creating some actually decent content. Just think about that before blabbing about why oh why are they doing this.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
i am not so sure about this thing .... but it should have optional setting in youtube creator studio.
Please consider my words as creator.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Question: is this the dumbest idea that YouTube has had, or the second dumbest? You wonder why internet creators are treated like crap like the more mainstream sources of media, well stupid and uncaring decisions like this are why. This is ridiculous. Very disappointed.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Seriously, YouTube must be run by socially-inept monkeys that hope this is the one version of the timeline that the monkeys produce the works of shakespeare from a million typewriters.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I have wasted 5 minutes trying to figure out how to say "I don't like it" without coming across as snarky. I don't like it. But I didn't like it when Google+ was forced on me either. But in the end it does not matter.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I just read the update and all the replies. You know what guys, we all should trust YouTube. They all know what they are doing. They all work hard for the platform, for the user experience and also for their creators. Just trust. Smile. :)
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Sorry, but im not agree about this
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
This is a terrible idea. This will ruin community engagement with creators. This is a bad thing to FORCE onto creators. At least make it optional.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I don't want this change...
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
thank you
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
This is stupid. Please don’t do this. I like having my exact number shown. I think it looks much more impressive.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Why? It's like you guys go into a board room and say "how can we piss them off now"
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Is this because of the James Charles scandal....if so im disappointed in YT. There is no value gained to abbreviate the subscriber count for any of us creators. I like seeing how many I have on a live view and this seems like that functionality will be lost. Also subscribers like seeing a channel grow and this takes that from the subscribers as well. A lose lose in my personal opinion.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Looking through the comments here, the comments on the creator channel video and comments on news articles and blog posts about this change, the general opinion about this move is 9 to 1 against. It would be overly kind to say your characterization of this as being an "improvement" is disingenuous at best. No-one wants this. Do you care what your creators and viewers want? Please give us some insight on the why & who at youtube decided to create this solution to a problem that doesn't exist... and to create a new problem with your solution that didn't exist before this decision.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Why do you hate your content creators so much?  All I ever see from YouTube is moves to lessen their experience, their revenue and their success.  Do you think you've grown too big for people to seek a better alternative, and therefore can rule with an iron fist?  Shame for not looking out for your content creators paramount above all else.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
This is bad, very bad. I guess individual people don't matter to Youtube anymore. They're all just one big rounded number.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I agree with this: "There should be a setting where you choose between these, not forcing us to see a specific version".
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I don't see the point of this: people cannot read long numbers anymore?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Really, YouTube?  This change is better because... why?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
ほんま意味わからん、こんなことして誰が得するの?
plz stop this step back “update”,at least give us a chance to vote this,thank u.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
More easy for some company to buy subs
What a 'great'idea!
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Ok I'm sorry but I fail to see when this ever has been a problem... Make this OPTIONAL! For many YouTubers even in the thousands, each sub matters, so if you can't even see and share new people joining because of an abriviated number. Then you're basically making these new subs matter less! Don't make YouTube more corporate, because that's what this is. A beginning to making YouTube more corporate!
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I think it's good -- like Instagram does!
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Please Youtube keep the existing system or this setting optional. A full number is much more impressive than abbreviated number and it actually helps get more subscribers which is very important for creators like me who have monetization disabled forever, as seeing subs growing faster and a heavier number brings a lot of satisfaction. Thank you!
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Please Youtube keep the existing system or this setting should be optional. Moreover channels like mine are suffering from unfair demonetization that really depress us from uploading consistently because all we always is that our Channel still not approve monetization and this is really depressing
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
"To create more consistency everywhere that we publicly display subscriber counts"

Sorry. I don't buy this rationale.

This change helps nobody, at all, and for those who follow subscriber counts like, say, the people making the videos, it actively hurts them. Therefore, why are you doing it? If you have a good reason no matter how unpalatable, make it public. That you have to change the display is very different to this being a random decision.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
this is just awful, fire youtube ceo
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Dang it what now
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
That's very bad idea, mr Google. But I think I understand what's happening here. They are trying to destroy channels analytics services based on their data (like Instagram made).
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Is this to do with the Pewdiepie/T series situation?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Please dont do this! :) nobody wants this :) we would all appreciate if you stopped :) please!
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
another useless change, that no one wanted.. why you do this google? why not start with the serious and hard questions that makes people quit on they'r dream?? damn it.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Don't do this. It would break sites like YouTube Realtime (https://akshatmittal.com/youtube-realtime/) and SocialBlade immediately. There should be some way to retain the previous numbers.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
That's the most stupidest thing I've read since the Alabama abortion law... 

Why would ANYONE want a short counter? Especially the part where sites that use the API will also get the short version. Do you want to destroy sites like socialblade? 

#JUSTICEFORSUBCOUNT
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
hi team youtube sir please reply my tweets  sir  i am very upset
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Ku soo dhawada channekayga
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Больше думать надо и работать над своими ошибками а не спорить о том чего сам не понимаешь !
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Who thought about this?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
If you want consistency, please go for the whole number instead of the abbreviation, please. Some countries do not even know what 1k means!
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Unless you let us decide how we want to see the sub count it is a terrible idea.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
This should be optional
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I don't think that it will help creators and viewers.
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I certainly appreciate this!!
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
@Mjay Night:

"The fact that this angers anyone is absurd. It literally changes nothing. Please stop making a mountain out of a mole hill. Complaining just to complain just to complain is ridiculous. If youtube didn't give you a heads up most of those upset about this wouldn't even notice it. So please take several seats."

The POINT of this is that there is NO net GAIN by doing this to our sub counts!  Youtube has 5 problems, of which NONE have been solved:  They are:

1.  Copyright System:  This system is broken and is being ABUSED, and has been allowed to remain that way for YEARS, and ANYONE can claim ANYTHING for ANY REASON, at ANY TIME, and the first thing Youtube does is to send Jordan, Marissa, Camilla, etc, out here to "talk down to us" about anything that happens here, making it sound awesome, when it STINKS like old garbage!  FIX COPYRIGHT - STOP allowing joe idiots the ability to claim what he does NOT own, and tell us who DOES own the copyrights.  Its so bad that Youtube would allow me to claim that I own the rights to the Declaration of Independance, which I don't.  WE CANT FIGHT THIS, and even if we were able to show that we had the rights to what we claim we have the rights to, we LOSE!

There is NOTHING wrong with the sub counts!

2.  Strikes:  Anyone can strike anything, without recourse, or the ability to APPEAL!  Appealing a strike is POINTLESS when the system is based on reviewers that have a "good reason" to take down something, and someone can "not like" something, report it, and it can result in termination, and in some cases, you CAN get  3 STRIKES in SECONDS, lose your channel, be denied an appeal, because all you get is "we have decided to keep you suspended" and NOTHING else is said to the person.  A STRIKE is a penalty, but you can ALWAYS go before a higher authority, like in a court of law and prove your case, but Youtube dont allow this, they are the SOLE judges of what is an offense, and they dont WANT to explain themselves, because someone would be able to argue AGAINST being unfairly treated.  STOP throwing strikes for NO REASON - Allow the creator the chance to FIGHT an accusation - STOP the 3 strikes in one offense mentality - PLEASE!!  stop striking everything in sight, and PUNISH the ASSHATS that claimed 400+ videos on one guys channel!  Sheeh!!

There is NOTHING wrong with Sub Counts

3.  @teamyoutube:  There are times when I believe team youtube is apathetic.  They DONT EVER respond to questions, concerns, comments, or problems RIGHT HERE, and they NEVER solve the problems of concerned youtube creators, when RULES cause problems.  They just "talk down to us" as this post does now, about sub counts, where there is NO NEED to change this.  teamyoutube wont explain something, they take 3-4 YEARS to get people decisions on monetization requests, they tell us, when we have a specific problem "'while we cannot get into specifics'" and other BULLSHIT.  Youtube CAN find a specific REASON to deny appeals, suspend channels, etc, and they let the bots and algorithims loose all over the place, but they CANT tell us a specific reason, when a channel hangs in the balance?  You need to be a YPP member before they do ANYTHING to help you, because you dont MATTER to the team - You sre simply a blot of spit on the nice clean office floor - If I were in charge, it would be a REQUIREMENT to respond to ALL requests within a 72 hour time frame, and they would be asked to render any and all aid that would be needed to help an individual.  teamyoutube does NOT have to deal with the stigma of being labelled: They dont have to deal with the heartache or dismay of losing channels forever, because the rules they make NEVER apply to them - Team youtube NEEDS to help the community and not be a closed-loop support system for the YPP members

There is NOTHING wrong with Sub Counts!!!

4. Rules: These rules are VAGUE and not explained too well, change on the FLY, and are NOT consistantly applied.  If I was a BIG channel, I would get a PASS because I make money for youtube, And I would be able to get the HELP I need.  The rules were made so that yt is protected, but they dont "protect" a creator from being attacked, bullied, shamed, or other rediculousnes, and Bullshit channel terminations, with NO recourse, and they dont wanna HEAR how people have been wronged, because of someones interpretation of the rules.  It is TIME for an OVERHAUL on ALL Rules, Policies, staff, reviews, Terminations and the like:  There is NO way to get a deleted channel restored, because the review team just finds you GUILTY UNTIL PROVEN INNOCENT, terminates you, and you are DEAD - FIX this.

There is NOTHING wrong with Sub Counts!!!

5.  EMAIL SUPPORT:  NEEDED:  and Youtube has again deemed something that is "broken."  We need better tech support for ALL, and less action that makes it like dealing with a guard at a jail.  Youtube has turned off comments on thousands of channels, but refuses to turn them back ON, or to explain RIGHT here why something is done.  I need to point out that issues with channels are a DAMN good reason to get specific, as the channel OWNER has the responsibility to follow the rules, but has the RIGHT to be given information so that they are NOT in violation of the rules.  Since Youtube NEVER responds because they were instructed NOT to, a person is without ANYTHING, and youtube is TOO HARD on the wrong crowd, and EASY on the ones they should be NAILING.

AGAIN YOU MORONS: 
There is NOTHING wrong with Sub Counts!!!
There is NOTHING wrong with Sub Counts!!!
There is NOTHING wrong with Sub Counts!!!
There is NOTHING wrong with Sub Counts!!!
There is NOTHING wrong with Sub Counts!!!

System is broken, but Youtube uses the wrong tools and fixes non issues - When the hell are they gonna GET real and hear the truth?

Disgusted by over reaction and no action!


Respectfully,

Brian
Brian
Last edited 5/22/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
+1 for what's said in this post.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I suppose this will be bad for Social Blade's live subscriber count and other features. As long as I can see the actual number somewhere this is not as big a deal, but I agree with the rest of people that say there's no need for this. It doesn't add to the experience and one can argue that it subtracts. I'm sure YouTube has other reasons for this change. My two cents.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Is this part of a larger trend toward neutering vanity metrics? There is a lot of "what" here, but very little "why." Just curious to glean any insights into whether this is part of a larger trend or a one-off action to streamline things.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Terrible update. Waste of time and there is no reason why this is needed.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
As someone who's been on since 2005, served on several Google/YouTube Roundtables, spoken at Vidcon several times, produced and still does voices for the old school show The Annoying Orange, I can unequivocally say that I hate this idea. For me, it seems this eliminates a part of a creator’s journey with  the fans... and it I think it's unnecessary. Nobody asked for this.

marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I don't like this. For small creators they want to see every number. I know I do.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Another example of Youtube being reactive to those two dummies who had an online bickering about things that had absolutely no contribution to human race. Youtube, you have a lot more important things to get on than trying to play equalizer on the playground. How about fixing that horrible analytic screen you butchered since this year?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Could I ask one thing? please clear my doubt. I had already created a youtube channel for 8D audio effect song which had already uploaded other youtube channel but it was not 8d effect. I created an 8d effect on my youtube channel. Is there any strike in my youtube channel? you are requested that please clear my doubt. Thank you.
Show less
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
hy
youtube me not subs
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
this is so uncool
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Uhm what is the real point of this... Just fix the stupid dashboard and all...
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
Awesome YouTube i love this idea
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/22/19
I am a small channel currently sitting at 1918 subs. That number matters to me and my subs. Not 1900, 1918 because my subscribers can watch with me as I hit 1920 and 1947 and 1998 and then 2000. We have done countdowns in my livestreams when I have been close to milestones. Now I won't be able to do that with them anymore. Really terrible idea.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Changing the API to go with this idiotic change is ridiculous: you really want to kill off Socialblade and all alternatives?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
This is horrible please do not do this. Atleast make it an optional setting.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
who asked for this, If it isn't broke dont fix it
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
When you want to not demonotize people's videos (including my videos) for no reason? Literally YouTube team does what no one asked features instead of fix the biggest problems first! And now I think the problems are most with the copyright system and the family-friendly system...
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
No one asked for this and this need to be in settings!!!
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
YouTube why do you do this stuff you just drive away people from the platform you need to ask what the people want not what you want.....
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Should it not be tested first?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
WHY NOT BOTH? show the exact number on mouse over
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Das mit dem ich mich, dass www.Y die 532
Last edited 5/23/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
no one asked for this
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Why does this exist?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
YouTube team you should motivate small channels not to give them no chance to grow!😥
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Whose idea was it to take away a crucial part of the website and the culture it has created?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Why, no one wants this
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
This is terrible, just make it an option...
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
This is an absolute terrible idea. This did bothered me when sub counts were abbreviated on youtube mobile app. Just make it an option. If you guys implement this feature we all will very disappointed
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Sub me my channel
Last edited 5/25/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
looking more standard
Last edited 5/23/19
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Who asked for this? I haven't heard anyone clamoring for consistency on this, and this seems to be a net negative for viewers, because they might have less trust that "4.2K" is real than "4,227".
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Reducing subscribers or minimizing them - this is a fight against the authors, not an improvement, and like any restrictions, limits and locks - always lead to a hosting crash.
cheating subscribers, most often for some reason to increase their number, but sometimes not special
• due to the fact that the subscribers themselves hide a special setting on their channel — to whom they are subscribed, and thus it is impossible to see them, since they have hidden what they have subscribed to
• blocking some channels for violations
• removal of subscribers' channels by themselves.
All this is a struggle - not an improvement. It is time to remember!

Now, as regards authorship and monetization. Once all topics are closed, send here and clarify everything you need to know YouTube!

Pure authorship does not exist in nature. Everyone has a personal style and creates everything in brick. Sharing authorship on objects or parts in a video and charging it for income or not is the same as depriving a company of all wages and bonuses and leaving only one person who sets a vector who is remote somewhere may not even create 1%. material, but the rest of the people will do 99% - but they will be thrown out of the turnover of this company and deprived of income. Naturally, this is not in the world!
The author receives income - for labor (piece-rate, time-based, it does not matter), and not for objects or parts in videos. Any video taken (by camera) is a definite work - it is rewarded. Any multi-level clip (video, sound effects, graphics, editing) is a big piece of work - even more so! Even if you theoretically imagine the situation - that the author creates one click of a photo in a clip or removes a 1 second video and leads the channel in this way - it is clear that there were some rights to impose, restrictions, that there is minimization of activity, etc. ... Although and in this situation - still insignificant, but work. Proof - posts in communities.

A person in the world is valued for his work and creativity. It doesn’t matter whether it’s a creator, director, producer, screenwriter, author, cameraman or picture boxer. All of them do not have direct authorship - but all have credits.

There are many styles - there is a video style, anime style, musical style, cinema style, gaming style and the like. All use someone else's content, it is and has been at all times. The clearest example is music videos (houses, cars), not to mention DJ mixes and so on ...

Do not learn to appreciate and fix the authors' work with algorithms - unfortunately, fail all ...
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Another step backwards I guess...
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
I think this will clean up the channel page on Youtube and make it more modern.

If we can hover over the subscriber count to see the exact amount I would be happier.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
I DONT LIKE THIS. I WANT TO SEE HOW MY CHANNEL IS GROWING EVERYDAY. I ALWAYS LOOK AT MY PHONE TO KNOW HOW MANY SUBS I HAVE
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Can you make it an option? Or at least let the people under 1,000 subscribers to see their subs. Because small channels like mine want to see if we are growing are subscribers.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
This is going to make subscribers worthless as each number represents a Unique individual. Not liking this update... YOUTUBE IS DYING SLOWLY. :(
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
I'm not understand this information
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Why not make the actual count show everywhere for "consistency? Who thought this is a good idea?
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Làm gì làm gì làm g
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Oh, so you can hide from people how you're manipulating our subs? Interesting. Well, my viewers have been watching my sub count for a while now so they're on to what you're doing. They know the truth--and so do we creators. If the data source for all of these locations is coming from the same place (and it should be), then there shouldn't be any discrepancy. That's how a database is supposed to work. The constant value is used in several equations so it's always the same value for each calculation, which should mean anytime that stat is accessed, it will return the same number no matter which app is using it. I think we need an objective third party auditor to monitor how you're getting your data and the accuracy of it because I'm really starting to doubt the validity of the stats you give us.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
That's probably going to affect Social Blade and Tubebuddy.  I would much rather see more accurate numbers and statistics.  I also much prefer Studio Classic over beta.  Find something better to do than common core dumb down.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
live subscriber count is irrelevant if you show abbreviated subscriber count, please don't impose this on us
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
Palash7869
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/23/19
how cana i solve losing subscribe plz help me that
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/24/19
Thanks for this update youtube! I don't understand why it's getting hate from everybody. This will be a good way to keep things simple and streamlined
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/24/19
I dare you to provide a downvote button for this post. Even rounding would not cover-up what most people already know. This unnecessary change is meant to protect larger channels and hamper third-party websites that track subscriber counts.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/24/19
This is a horrible idea.  If you want to do it public facing, fine.  But taking away the API exact count would serve absolutely no purpose and no other apps or sites are doing this.

Please reconsider this whole decision, but certainly don't take away the API exact count!
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/24/19
DO NOT DO THIS, YOUTUBE.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/24/19
YouTube, this is a terrible idea. We want exact sub counts, but i guess you wont listen. we should all move somewhere else.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/24/19
This is actually the worst thing that has ever come across. YouTube, you NEVER literally listen to the community and you are ignoring such complaints like nothing happened! That is dead wrong, and please, please, please, please, PLEASE fix these issues, and quit demonetizing our videos! This is wrong, and we don't deserve this! Please... fix this stupid issue. Also don't even think about changing this important subscriber counts. I need the full count just to keep track. It makes it more difficult to tell whether our subscribers are joining in or not, and I don't think this is a good idea AT ALL.

You don't even know what you are doing to our poor fellow YouTubers and creators. They need this feature, and and if you're doing this, we cannot tell anymore! We can't tell if we are getting new subscribers or not! What in the world s wrong with you these days?! Please, YouTube, for once, LISTEN TO THE COMMUNITY AND FIX ALL OF THE ISSUES AND STOP DEMONETIZING OUR VIDEOS! Ugh, geez, do I have to yell or what? <:(
marked this as an answer
Helpful?
5/24/19
This is such a horrible idea, it might’ve been done in the recent drama, but this ain’t it chief.
marked this as an answer
Helpful?