Picasa 3.9.0 strips all Exif information after saving photos to computer?
To confirm, I just edited almost 500 photos from a working trip to Israel, primarily adding captions to the images (today!)!!!!
PICASA COMPLETELY STRIPPED _ALL_ OF THE EXIF DATA INCLUDING THE GPS LOCATION AND DIRECTION COORDINATES _INCLUDING_ THE ORIGINAL IMAGE DATE AND TIME INFORMATION.
Version 3.9.137 reported as "current"
Here's an example of the _ONLY_ EXIF data remaining after simply adding a caption.
Filename - RRIsrael5-14-357.JPG
Software - Picasa
DateTime - 2014:05:28 18:49:18 <- this is the picasa _EDIT_ date/time, not the image date/time
ExifOffset - 78
ExifVersion - 0220
And, to underscore how totally STUPID this bug is, THE CAPTION RESIDES IN THE IPTC INFORMATION, AND NOT IN THE EXIF INFORMATION.
There is _nothing_ in options or elsewhere that references saving the EXIF data when editing and, obviously, no warning that the EXIF deletions will occur.
Threads in _this_ forum discussing EXIF DATA STRIPPING PROBLES date back to 2009! Posts indicate that problem has been FIXED, but I can assure everyone that if you add a caption using Picasa TODAY, you _will loose_ potentially critical EXIF data.
Next question... Does anyone know of any software that will allow merging EXIF information using backups of the images or are ALL OF THE EDITS MADE OVER TEN HOURS going to have to be redone???... using other image software. This is probably not even going to be an option since the initial part of the image preparation process was to rename the files to reflect the job.
Talk about trust issues... there's now a total lack of trust about using picasa, and anything else google at this location.
Very sincerely, and very disgusted,
Most of the 500 images were taken with a google Nexus 4... one would expect that even if the EXIF data was stored in a "non-standard" format, that the picasa programmers would at least take google products into consideration.
Well, I can assure everyone that it does not happen here, and never happened before.
I understand your frustration but cannot imagine that this happens by adding captions in Picasa. Something else could be goin on, but no idea what ...
Anything else you did to these photos ?
Can you reproduce the error on say a new pic from the camera you simply copied to the computer ?
I hope you have good backups.
You can download every version here: http://www.filehippo.com/download_picasa
But 3.8 was very different from 3.9 : many data are stored differently. I would not do it.
Most users do not seem to have this problem with the actual version.
That's hard to understand since there are a number of posts on this and other forums dating back years that report the same issue.
>> I understand your frustration but cannot imagine that this happens by adding captions in Picasa. <<
>> Something else could be goin on, but no idea what ...Anything else you did to these photos ? <<
This is not imagination, but now documented fact as I carefully reviewed each step in the process.
The pictures were uploaded to the computer, picasa was opened, picasa scanned the new images and we viewed them.
Of the almost 500 images _Picasa_ showed location markers on around two thirds of the thumbnails which is normal since the phone (a Nexus 4) may not have established a GPS location when the image is snapped.
Before the captions were added, we reviewed a number (probably about 20%) of the images with location markers and went to the google maps locations of those image using picasa to link to google maps.
NO other process or software touched the photos between the time we reviewed the locations and the original location and other EXIF data was deleted.
Note that I posted the complete EXIF data set of one of the captioned images in my above post.
Those few remaining EXIF lines which show "Picasa" and the date/time of the _picasa_ edits are the damming evidence that they were generated _by picasa_ leaving _none_ of the original EXIF camera data in the edited image.
As for the process, captions were added to _all_ photographs. Two photographs of the 500 were reoriented. No other edits were made.
>> Can you reproduce the error on say a new pic from the camera you simply copied to the computer ? <<
No, I'm not going to do that. The information in my posts carefully explains all of the evidence that I have collected. It's now up to the google team to either use or discard my research and frustration to figure out what is going on inside the software.
I will collect several "before and after" images and post them for investigation, but it will probably be later this weekend before I can do that.
I _will_ note that since my original post, I have found a handful of of images where the captions were added by picasa retained the original EXIF data, but most were scrubbed.
Since this evidence is so clear, we will do no more edits or captioning using picasa but go back to other software to prevent another disaster such as this one and only use picasa to create and upload albums.
>> I hope you have good backups. <<
Backups we have... but what we do not have, and will never recover, is the time that was expended to sit down and create almost 500 captions. I have yet to find any process that would allow syncing the caption fields back to (copies of) the original images.
Thanks for your response. Please remember that it is extremely easy to assume that the problem is on the user end when you have not experienced it in your own use of the product. Unfortunately, that assumption goes a long way to assuring that serious problems in software will take a long time, if ever, to get resolved.
Respectfully, but sincerely,
Some community members might have badges that indicate their identity or level of participation in a community.
Member levels indicate a user's level of participation in a forum. The greater the participation, the higher the level. Everyone starts at level 1 and can rise to level 10. These activities can increase your level in a forum:
- Post an answer.
- Having your answer selected as the best answer.
- Having your post rated as helpful.
- Vote up a post.
- Correctly mark a topic or post as abuse.
Having a post marked and removed as abuse will slow a user's advance in levels.
View profile in forum?
To view this member's profile, you need to leave the current Help page.
Report abuse in forum?
This comment originated in the Google Product Forum. To report abuse, you need to leave the current Help page.
Reply in forum?
This comment originated in the Google Product Forum. To reply, you need to leave the current Help page.